A guide to nude pencil eyeliner: what is the best color for a natural look?

A guide to nude pencil eyeliner: what is the best color for a natural look?

For those wanting to achieve a natural, subtle look with their makeup, nude waterline eyeliners are the way to go. But which color works best for achieving that look? In this guide, we will explore what beige eyeliner pencil does and compare the popular shades - white, beige, and gray - in terms of which is better for a natural look. We'll also discuss using an eye-brightening pencil for your waterline. 

What does beige eyeliner do?

A beige eyeliner pencil can help to create a natural look for your eyes. It can also brighten the area around your eyes and make them look wider awake. Beige eyeliner pencils can be applied close to the lash line or on the waterline. Applying close to the lash line creates a softer, more natural look. If you want a more dramatic look, you can apply it on the waterline.

Choosing the right shade for your skin tone

When it comes to finding the perfect nude waterline eyeliner, it's all about knowing your skin tone. Similar to any other makeup product, the right nude shade will make all the difference in how your look comes together. If you're not sure where to start, here's a quick guide to choosing the right shade of nude waterline eyeliner for your skin tone:

Fair skin

The best shades of nude waterline eyeliner for you are ones with a pink or peachy undertone. These will help brighten your eyes and give you a natural-looking flush of color. Avoid nudes that are too dark or yellow-toned, as these can make your eyes look sunken and tired.

Medium skin

Look for pencils with a caramel or bronze undertone - these will give your eyes warmth and definition. Avoid nudes that are too pale or ashy, as they can wash out your features.

Dark skin

The best shades of nude waterline eyeliner for dark skin tones are rich and chocolaty browns. These will complement your complexion without looking too heavy or harsh. Avoid nudes that are too light or pink-toned, as they can make your eyes look washed out.

Which color is best for a natural look?

In addition to skin tone, there are a few things to consider when choosing nude waterline eyeliner. 

Eye color

  • If you have blue eyes, look for a nude pencil with pink or peachy undertones. 
  • If you have green eyes, look for a nude pencil with peachy or gold undertones. 
  • Look for a nude pencil with chocolate or gold undertones if you have brown eyes.

What look are you going for? 

  • If you want a natural look, go for a matte finish. 
  • If you want a more glam look, go for a shimmery finish.

Nude waterline eyeliner color  


White eyeliner is ideal for creating a subtle yet dramatic look. It can be used to create a winged eyeliner look or to define your lash line. 

Pros: Can brighten up the eyes and make them appear wider. 

Cons: Can be difficult to apply evenly; can look stark against darker skin tones.


A beige eyeliner pencil is perfect for those who want to enhance their natural beauty and create a more subtle look. Beige eyeliner pencils can line the lower lash line or create a soft, smokey eye. 

Pros: Gives off a softer effect than white eyeliner; can be easier to apply evenly. 

Cons: Can start to look muddy on fair skin tones; may show up less on darker skin tones.


It's not too dark, so it won't make your eyes look sunken in, and it's not too light, so it won't make them look overly bright. Plus, the cool tone of gray helps to offset any redness in your eyelids.

Pros: Easily defines the eyes; looks great on all skin tones. 

Cons: May look too intense if you're going for a natural look; it can start to look smudgy and messy over time.

Best brightening eyeliner for waterline

If you want a natural look with your pencil eyeliner, use a nude one on your waterline. Not only will it brighten up your eyes, but it will also help to create the illusion of wider and more awake eyes.

When choosing a nude waterline eyeliner, find one that matches your skin tone as closely as possible. A good rule of thumb is to match your pencil to the color of your foundation - this will ensure a seamless and natural look.

Once you've found the perfect nude waterline eyeliner shade, apply it along your waterline and blend it with a cotton bud for a soft and gentle finish. 

Best practices for eye-brightening pencils

  • Always start with a clean slate. This means using a good quality makeup remover to remove any traces of previous liner or shadow. 
  • Take your time lining your eyes. A light hand is key to achieving a natural look. Start by lining the inner rim of the eye and working your way outwards. 
  • Set the liner with a matching shadow or powder. This will help to prevent any smudging or transfer throughout the day.

Final thoughts 

Nude waterline eyeliner is a great way to achieve a natural look that won't overpower your eyes. Experimenting with different colors and formulas can help you find the perfect shade for your skin tone and eye color. 

Shop now to find your best nude eyeliner.  

Back to blog